| Turnstone
Systems Inc.s {TSTN}
initial public offering has soared on its opening trading day,
trading as high as 90 on Tuesday.
Late Monday, the company priced its 3 million share offering
at 29 a share, above its most-recent range of 23 and 25 and
a previous range of 15 to 17.

Turnstone Systems post-IPO stock performance
Analysts say the companys business model gives it a good
shot at becoming a critical digital subscriber line (DSL) infrastructure
provider.
"Turnstone actually has some major customers and a useful
product, which is more than you can say for some other recent
IPOs," adds Kathie Hackler, principal analyst at Dataquest,
based in San Jose, Calif. "They should do OK."
Mountain View, Calif.-based Turnstone sells hardware and software
that helps DSL service providers perform remote tests on copper
phone lines to determine the ability of individual lines to
transport data at high speeds.
The tests can be conducted without having to send service technicians
into the field. Turnstones software also maintains logs
of DSL line and circuit quality that are useful whenever customers
move or for a variety of other purposes.
"I think they have some real upside potential," says
Gary Kim, an analyst at NxGen Research, a Chicago-based research
firm that tracks the DSL market. "I dont know of
anyone else that is further along in focusing on their part
of the market. Theyre mining a potentially quite lucrative
vein."
Analysts say Turnstones DSL testing products are popular
with DSL service providers, particularly competitive local exchange
carriers (CLECs), such as Santa Clara, Calif.-based Covad Communications
Inc. {COVD},
which competes with regional Bell operating companies (RBOCs),
also known as Baby Bells, in a number of markets.
"Simply stated, Turnstones system can be the difference
between a DSL service provider like Covad making money on an
account or not making money on an account," Kim says.

Covad Communications 52-week stock performance
It often costs a DSL service provider several hundred dollars
to add each new DSL subscriber, Kim says, particularly if the
service provider must manually test each line. Although available
DSL customer retention data are scant, Kim says DSL service
providers might only generate between $300 to $400 in income
over the life of an individual DSL account if DSL users follow
the pattern established by cell-phone customers who, on average,
switch providers every two or three years.
"Youre talking about saving a truck roll each time
you sign up a new customer," Hackler says. "Its
all about provisioning each new line as cost effectively as
possible."
At present, CLECs constitute the lions share of current
Turnstone customers.
"The CLECs have been the most aggressive about rolling
out DSL in the business market," says Mark Zohar, senior
analyst at Forrester Research, based in Cambridge, Mass. "The
RBOCs dont want to cannibalize their existing T-1 businesses,
and they also have a pretty tight relationship with their existing
suppliers."
One key to Turnstones strategy involves using the line
quality testing data obtained to help DSL service providers
create databases that can be used for a variety of other purposes.
DSL service providers frequently find themselves in disputes
with RBOCs, for example, which are required by law to lease
certain facilities to the CLECs and to maintain fixed levels
of service quality.
"The Turnstone information could be very useful in a courtroom
or before regulatory agencies," Kim says. "CLECs are
spending a lot of time in disputes with the local incumbents,
so this gives them the evidence and information they need."
In addition, Kim says a trend toward so-called service level
agreements, which guarantee DSL users fixed minimum transmission
speeds, can only be honored if DSL service providers know exactly
which circuits can handle data at sufficient speeds.
"Internet traffic goes through many different networks,"
Kim says. "Service providers need to know the speed each
step along the way."
That need, Kim says, could eventually put Turnstone in a potentially
lucrative position as a kind of DSL Internet traffic cop, controlling
data from a variety of DSL service providers that, taken together,
could be used to more efficiently route traffic over several
interlocking DSL networks.
Analysts say prospects of such derivative products and services
constitute Turnstones strongest suit moving forward. The
companys success over time hinges largely on its ability
to use its existing products as a foot-in-the-door that lets
the company offer DSL services providers an ever-growing menu
of products and services.
"Their software gives them the opportunity to do more
as time goes on," Hackler says.
Competitors in the DSL equipment market include major players
such as Harris Corporation, Hekimian Laboratories Inc., Hewlett-Packard
Co. {HWP}
and Nortel Networks Corp. {NT},
among many others. Another competitor, Lucent Technologies,
Inc. {LU},
offers similar but less-powerful DSL test equipment of its own
but also has an original equipment manufacturer deal with Turnstone
that allows Lucent to sell co-branded Turnstone products.
"Those companies have bigger fish to fry," Kim says.
"Im not too worried about that kind of competition.
Turnstone has a clear focus on the market, while companies like
Lucent or Nortel have a lot of other things they need to worry
about."
In addition to Lucent, Turnstones current customers include
two of the nations biggest CLEC DSL service providers,
Covad Communications and Rhythms NetConnections Inc., based
in Englewood, Colo.
"The fact that Covad, the largest national DSL competitor,
has signed up with them for local loop management speaks very
well for them," Zohar says. "Its certainly a
validation of their product."
Turnstone, which was established in January 1998, posted a
loss of $707,000 on revenue of $14.7 million for the nine months
ended Sept. 30, as compared with a loss of $2.9 million on zero
revenue for the same period a year earlier.
|