There could be some very good news for
biotechnology investors just around the corner.
If analysts are right, Cambridge, Mass.-based
Biopure Inc. {BPUR}
is less than a year away from achieving the long-awaited goal
of obtaining government permission to start selling the first
practical human blood substitute.
According to a variety of sources, the
company is nearing the apparently successful completion of the
final Phase III stage of testing its new product, called Hemopure,
and has begun to prepare the data needed to file a Biologic
Licensing Application with the Food and Drug Administration.
Analysts warn that its still possible
Biopure's new product might yet prove a disappointment.
But they add that all signals indicate
that is now unlikely, given the very late stage of Biopure's
product-development process. As such, several analysts say they
expect the company's stock to move up rather sharply over the
near term, with some saying the stock could more than double
over the next year, assuming the new product receives FDA approval
as expected.
Biopure's stock has bounced around a
lot over the past year along with other stocks in the sector,
many of which were hammered particularly hard in February and
March. Analysts say there could be more volatility in the stock
over the short run, which should abate once the outcome of the
current testing and marketing approval process becomes more
certain.
"This isn't a stock for widows and
orphans," says Larry Neibor, an analyst with Robert W.
Baird & Co. in Milwaukee. "But all of the other contenders
in this area have failed to make it through clinical tests due
to safety concerns, and that's obviously not a problem here."
 |
| One-year performance of Biopure,
Inc. |
Neibor notes that several previous high-profile
attempts to test new blood substitutes in human patients were
halted midway through the process, due to concerns over jeopardizing
the safety of the subjects. Biopure, by contrast, has successfully
jumped that hurdle by moving through the human testing phase
thus far without incident. In addition, the firm is already
using a related Hemopure product, called Oxyglobin, in veterinary
medicine applications where its safety and efficacy have already
been well established.
One of the breakthrough advantages of
Hemopure's product is that it is both species and blood-type
agnostic. The company says its product can be used in both animals
and humans without regard to specific blood type.
The product's features make it an ideal
candidate for a variety of medical applications, such as use
on military battlefields, in elective surgery or by emergency
medical personnel such as ambulance crews who aren't currently
able to stock fresh blood supplies. There is an estimated shortage
of about 250,000 thousand units of blood per year in the Unites
States, representing about 2% of the overall supply, according
to estimates by J.P Morgan.
Estimates of the potential overall dollar
value of the market are hard to come by since it doesn't exist
yet. Biopure is, however, charging about $125 for every unit
of Oxyglobin purchased by vets. The company says it is able
to manufacture 100,000 units of Hemopure a year and has plans
to boost that to 500,000 with the next three to four years.
Neibor has a $60 12-month price target
on Biopure's stock, which he rates "buy-speculative,"
his firm's most-enthusiastic recommendation for investors who
can tolerate some degree of risk.
At least three other companies are also
conducting tests on human blood substitutes. Biopure, however,
is the only company developing a human blood substitute based
on a manipulation of low-cost, always-available cow blood. The
other firms, which include Alliance Pharmaceuticals Corp. {ALLP},
Canada-based Hemosol Inc. {TSE: HML}
and Northfield Laboratories Inc. {NFLD}
are using a variety of other approaches, which may also prove
valid, that are formulated from either harder-to-obtain expired
human blood or recombinant technologies that have often proven
problematic in the past.
The problem with expired human blood
is there is so little of it available, given current blood-supply
shortages, which usually means most blood is used well before
it has a chance to expire. Likewise, recombinant technologies
can yield less-expensive synthetic alternatives but have, unfortunately,
also proven prone to causing unwanted side effects of the type
that can be less common with biologically based substances.
"Alliance Pharmaceuticals is in
the hunt with a product that could be cheaper to produce,"
says Alfred Mansour, Ph.D., chairman and CEO of BiotechWatch.com,
an online service based in Franklin, Mich., which tracks the
progress of biotech firms.
But Mansour notes that Alliance's product
is technically not a blood substitute at all but rather is designed
to prevent the need for blood transfusions in the first place.
Hemosol's product might also be competitive, he says, but a
recent trial in Canada left investors confused when the company's
original results, which were later amended, didn't show a reduction
in the need for blood transfusions.
There have also been troubles at Northfield,
with major shareholders of that firm publicly questioning management's
ability to successfully bring its new product to market, according
to Mansour.
"Biopure's results thus far have
been positive," Mansour says. "Therefore, the likelihood
of clinical success is quite good."
Development of a substitute for human
blood is something of a holy grail within the biotech industry.
There have been several conspicuous failures in recent years,
most notably at the once highflying Somatogen, which was acquired
by Baxter International Inc. {BAX}
in 1998 before it became fully apparent the company's approach
wasn't working. But many biotech companies have continued to
work on the problem, driven on by increasing shortages of human
blood supplies, which have just a 42-day shelf life when properly
refrigerated.
Biopure's product, by contrast, has at
least a two-year shelf life and doesn't require any refrigeration.
"Biopure has been operating mostly
under the radar screen, particularly with institutional accounts,"
says Phil Nalbone, biotech analyst at Salomon Smith Barney in
San Francisco. "But we're very enthusiastically recommending
the stock ahead of the key milestones that typically drive valuation
in medical stocks."
The analysts say that if Biopure wins
FDA approval as expected sometime next year, its stock performance
might approach that of other biotech stocks, such as IDEC Pharmaceuticals
Corp. {IDPH},
Immunex Corp. {IMNX}
and Medimmune Inc. {MEDI},
all of which soared fourfold or more after their new products
won FDA approval over the past few years.
Jim McCamant, publisher of The Medical
Stock Technology Newsletter, based in Berkeley, Calif.,
says he is cautiously optimistic about Biopure's prospects.
But the big disappointment at Somatogen
left McCamant somewhat wary.
"If they announce the results people
are expecting the stock will go up," McCamant says. "But
typically you don't really know until they have done all the
analysis, which is what's happening now. They'll also have to
prove the can make it in large quantities. But it could be a
very good speculative play."
Franklin Berger, an analyst at J. P.
Morgan in New York, upgraded Biopure's stock to "buy"
from "market perform" last week, raising his 12-month
price target from 30 to 40 after the company announced the hiring
of Dr. Michael Hensley as head of clinical and regulatory affairs
at the company. Berger says Hensley has the "skill sets
and experience required" to guide the company through the
final steps involved in winning FDA approval.
"One of the biggest users of blood
is for hip and knee replacements," Berger adds. "And
guess what's happening as all the baby boomers get older? You
get older hips and older knees that need to be replaced. What
Biopure offers is a net new addition to the blood supply. The
only question now is how safe it is, and we expect to get the
thumbs up on that in January or February."
Full commercial approval would then be
expected by year-end 2001, assuming the company requests and
receives expedited processing from the FDA, as anticipated.
|